The proper discipline to study theism isnt science at all, it is philosophy of religion. What is wrong, if anything, with richard dawkins refutations. I posted a small portion of it on facebook which started a. More than two decades before richard dawkins called belief in god a delusion, george h. I will focus on dawkins arguments in his 2006 book, the god delusion. He has no hesitancy and doubt to state his outspoken rebuttal against god arguments and logical fallacy often used by apologists. The god delusion richard dawkins read online free books. The argument against richard dawkins the god delusion intelligent c the intelligent community, barry krusch on.
Introduction more than a decade has passed since the release of the infamous the god delusion by richard dawkins. Dawkins and daniel dennett whose recent breaking the spell is his contribution to this genre are the touchdown twins of current academic atheism. If this book works as i intend, religious readers who open it will be atheists when they put it down. Dec 08, 2006 these letters have now been published in a slightly revised form in the dawkins letters. On pages 1578 of his book, dawkins summarizes what he calls the central argument of my book. A digital billboard, sponsored by the american atheists organization, on display in new york. Stripped of their veneer of scientific authority, his arguments are silly.
The volume has received wide coverage, fueled much passionate debate and caused not a little confusion. There is, i think, one good thing about the god delusion. And yet my view of the world is very different to that of richard dawkins. This challenging book sold 50,000 copies in hardback within a few weeks of publication, and a paperback is set to follow. Within weeks it became the most hotly debated topic, with dawkins himself branded as either saint or sinner for presenting his hardhitting, impassioned rebuttal of religion of all types. Surely there are things not dreamt of in our philosophy, not to mention in our science but that fact is not a reason to believe in supernatural beings. The god delusion by richard dawkins mark vernon questions richard dawkins state of selfdelusion. The following comes directly from dawkins book, except that i chose to shorten a few of the points here for the sake of brevity. Feb 25, 2014 thats not to say that i think everything is within the scope of human knowledge. Dawkins delusional arguments against god summit ministries. These letters have now been published in a slightly revised form in the dawkins letters. A refutation of richard dawkins by thomas crean, o. Response to richard dawkins book, the god delusion. Although he obviously didnt disprove god, i think he did a thorough job of eliminating a need for god to explain anything.
Buy a cheap copy of the god delusion book by richard dawkins. Jun 10, 2009 most of the god delusion argues against god and christianity, with chapter 4, why there is almost certainly no god, stating the case most strongly. Worldrenowned scientist richard dawkins writes in the god delusion. Although he didnt invent all the arguments, mind you, nor did he break new ground in ontology although he does give it a new perspective, he has the bravery, integrity, humor and explanatory skill to describe the god delusion clearly to laymen and dilettantes like us. Dawkins sets out not only to defend atheism but to portray its worldview as morally and aesthetically pleasing in a way that atheist thinkers of the past say, nietzsche didnt. Jan 15, 2017 god is not great christopher hitchens audio book p1 duration. Richard dawkins argument for atheism in the god delusion. January, 2008 this short book is an incredibly erudite disquisition and then absolute discrediting of richard dawkins in his book the god delusion. The god delusion research papers discuss richard dawkins arguments against the existence of god.
In his 2006 bestseller, the god delusion, richard dawkins, the charles simonyi professor of the public understanding of science at oxford university, presents an argument against god that mirrors the rhetoric used by the religious fundamentalists he sets out to criticize. Atheism, scepticism, rambles, doubt, secularism, and archive robertxlester moved to robertwlester 558,156 views. There are several flaws in dawkins numerous arguments. He shows how religion fuels war, foments bigotry, and abuses children, buttressing his points with historical and contemporary evidence. Th god delusion is an excellent book to convince any intelligent reader that there is good arguments to negate god existence, to suspect holy books bible included of having nothing to do with revelation, and to establish other sources of morality than scripture. Having dispensed with the deity, dawkins then explains why so many people are religious when there is no god and goes on to explicate the evils he thinks emanate uniquely from religion. The ontological argument says that god must exist by his very nature. Aug 10, 2019 dawkins arguments appear to be science, but are distinctly unscientific. Richard dawkins book the god delusion is immensely popular and has been hailed as a convincing defense of atheism. Richard dawkins best argument against god is the worst argument in western history. Has anyone successfully refuted any of the points made in the. The designer hypothesis immediately raises the larg. Aug 11, 2010 i will focus on dawkins arguments in his 2006 book, the god delusion.
The god delusion continues his thoughtprovoking tradition. The god delusion richard dawkins book is a passionate argument against religious believes. Jadore nest probablement pas le bon mot, vu le sujet du livre. The god delusion makes a compelling case that notion in god is not simply mistaken nevertheless in all probability deadly. Craig venter, decoder of the human genome the god delusion is smart, compassionate, and true. But before you come on to your big argument you try in this chapter to deal with some of the arguments that theists put forward for the existence of god. Dawkins, it appears, has sometimes been told by theologians that he sets up straw men only to bowl them over, a charge he rebuts in this book. To call it influential would be an understatement, as the book sold more than three million copies in eight years and a number of different authors, including alvin plantinga, michael ruse, richard swinburne, william lane craig. The god delusion is easier to argue with and maybe even win, if only in my mind. A constant theme of his books is asking what created god. The god delusion richard dawkins richard dawkins is one of the supreme expositors of modern evolutionary biology. I suppose this was the first time i got a good, simple explanation of how. The god delusion is an extended diatribe against religion in general and belief in god in particular. The god delusion is a 2006 book by english biologist richard dawkins, a professorial fellow at new college, oxford, and former holder of the charles simonyi chair for the public understanding of science at the university of oxford.
Smith elucidated the rational critique of religion in his essential book atheism. About twelve years ago evolutionary biologist richard dawkins published the god delusion. Dawkins arguments appear to be science, but are distinctly unscientific. More than a decade has passed since the release of the infamous the god delusion by richard dawkins. This is the centerpiece of his case against the existence of god. Aug 21, 2008 the god delusion was a book to introduce these arguments to the masses it is not a serious attack on theism imo.
Jan 14, 2014 what if most modern arguments against religious belief have been attacking the wrong god all along. The god delusion by richard dawkins 1573 words bartleby. One of the greatest challenges to the human intellect has been to explain how the complex, improbable appearance of design in the universe arises. Jan, 2011 we started a book club with some friends who enjoy reading some of the same books we do. The god delusion does not meet the standards of rationality that a topic as important as religion requires. It is therefore entirely reasonable to believe that the god delusion is a book written by richard dawkins because it is supported by all the evidence.
Dawkins asserts that the the argument from improbability, properly deployed, comes close to proving that god. Paper masters will help you write your research paper on the god delusion and make sure you understand the complex examination of. The argument against richard dawkins the god delusion a secular analysis of the logical fallacies in the god delusion last modified july 20, 2008. What do you think of richard dawkins argument for atheism in the god delusion. The argument against richard dawkins the god delusion at. Lets see how those arguments fall apart on proper scrutiny. Dawkins bluntly articulates his arguments in this book in clear details and sometime the way he challenge religions doctrine will sound offensive to some people. Sep 23, 2006 the god delusion by richard dawkins 416pp, bantam.
Grayling the god argument is a very respectful, thoughtprovoking and accessible book that addresses the case against religion while making the compelling case for a superior ethical way of living, humanism. A preeminent scientist and the worlds most prominent atheist asserts the irrationality of belief in god and the grievous harm religion has inflicted on. For our latest selection we read and discussed richard dawkinss lightning rod book the god delusion. Regardless of what dawkins think about a deist god, if he accepted it, then his argument against christians god existence contradicts his own argument.
It is written from a christian perspective as a response to arguments put forth in the god delusion by richard dawkins. In the god delusion, dawkins contends that a supernatural creator almost certainly does not exist and that belief. The god delusion book by richard dawkins thriftbooks. Specifically, we cant know for sure if god shows evidence of design, since he is not even a physical entity god is a spirit 1. The god delusion offers little that is new but packages the arguments against belief in god s and against the practise of religion entertainingly and well. Apr 23, 2007 what do you think of richard dawkins argument for atheism in the god delusion. The god delusion makes a compelling case that belief in god is not just wrong but potentially deadly. This book presents arguments both for and against the existence of god, but it gives a far more sophisticated look at the pro arguments than the god delusion. The fourth chapter of the god delusion is what richard dawkins considers to be his most convincing argument that no gods exist. In his latest book, the god delusion houghton mifflin, 2006, dawkins thesis is that belief in a supernatural creator qualifies as a delusion, which he defines as a persistent false belief held in the face of strong contradictory evidence. It moreover provides exhilarating notion into some nice advantages of atheism to the individual and society, not the least of which is a clearer, extra true appreciation of the universes wonders than any faith may ever muster. While this may be the case, it is only fair to assess his book on his own terms, namely as a case for theism being a. The selfish gene was a book that set the standard of how scientific ideas should be presented.
Most of the god delusion argues against god and christianity, with chapter 4, why there is almost certainly no god, stating the case most strongly. Critics have said its a book stronger on rhetoric than substantive arguments. In his book the god delusion, prominent atheist richard dawkins has brought together the many arguments against the likelihood of god s existence. It was a religiously eclectic group consisting of two christians, a muslim, and two skeptics.
Research papers on the god delusion by richard dawkins are required for either literature courses or religion classes. Atheistic scientists like richard dawkins in his book the god delusion present specious arguments to disprove the existence of god. Richard dawkins the god delusion on pages 157 and 158 of the god delusion, richard dawkins encapsulates the central argument of his book in six points. I have been a big fan of dawkins from the time i read the selfish gene. Read as a catalogue of religious excess and abuse and pulling no punches, it serves a purpose. Even worse is his own argument against god s existence. In september 1997 richard dawkins allowed an australian film crew into his oxford home, only to realise in the course of a particularly. The god delusion by richard dawkins 1598 words 7 pages. Richard dawkins best argument against god is the worst. The god delusion by richard dawkins audiobook youtube. Apr 24, 2007 dawkins delusional arguments against god april 24, 2007 article 10min read british ethologist 1 richard dawkins, professor for the public understanding of science at oxford university, is a longtime popularizer of darwinian evolution, ardent proponent of atheism, and prominent debunker of religion. Oct 15, 2017 soon after this were dawkins responses to arguments for gods existence and his own arguments against it, which i really appreciated. Richard dawkinss new book, the god delusion, seems to be preaching to the choir, since the vast majority of his apologetics is either old and refuted or strawman in nature. This book does nothing to damage that, even though it is not as logically cohesive as the selfish gene.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. While europe is becoming increasingly secularized, the rise of religious fundamentalism, whether. The title of this book immediately betrays the bias of the authoreven for those unacquainted with the writings of this professor of the socalled public understanding of science of oxford university, richard dawkins. If you can stomach more of him you might want to give that one a read, if only to see his slightly more grounded arguments. Has anyone successfully refuted any of the points made in. Dawkins has written, perhaps, the most powerful set of arguments against the alleged supernatural god ever written. In ten chapters, he presents the most commonly raised points in favor of religion, for the existence of a god, and in favor of tolerating both, for then to meticulously debunk them and expose their fallacies.
The proof that the first premise is false can be shown by using it against dawkins own preferred universe designer the multiverse. The god delusion caused a sensation when it was published in 2006. The temptation to attribute the appearance of design to actual design itself is a false one, because the designer hypothesis immediately raises the larger problem of who designed the. Five rational arguments why god very probably exists. Desmond morris, author of the naked ape and the human animal richard dawkins is the leading soothsayer of our time.
Page numbers removed, paragraphs joined, fully formatted and common ocr errors have been largely removed. As dawkins australian tour continues, it seems a good time to return to the book. As far as theology goes, dawkins has an enormous amount in common with ian paisley and american tv evangelists. The least satisfying part of this book is dawkinss treatment of the traditional arguments for the existence of god. Reading the god delusion provides a very different experience. When i settled down to read richard dawkins latest book, the god delusion, i was surprised at just how much of his book i agreed with. Richard dawkins is the noted biologist who has held the charles simonyi chair for the public understanding of science at oxford university. Anticipating the accusation of fundamentalism, dawkins argues. Dear dr dawkins, we are getting closer to your proof that god is a delusion. He eviscerates the major arguments for religion and demonstrates the supreme improbability of a supreme being.
Those who are baffled by the whole god belief phenomenon might find it all a bit obvious, but perhaps there is a middle ground audience of those who, without really being convinced of its. In september 1997 richard dawkins allowed an australian film crew into his oxford home, only. Atheist fundamentalism and the denial of the divine is a book by the theologian alister mcgrath and the psychologist joanna collicutt mcgrath. It completely entranced me in my high school years. Dawkinss writing gives the impression of clarity, but his readable style.
In his rather lengthy book, dawkins seeks not only to prove that the existence of god is so improbable as to be dismissible but also. I think many arguments for the existence of a god depend on the insufficiencies of human cognition. Dawkinss writing gives the impression of clarity, but his readable style can cover over major conceptual confusions. The god delusion by richard dawkins, transworld publishers, london, 2006. It also offers exhilarating insight into the advantages of atheism to the individual and society, not the least of which is a clearer, truer appreciation of the universes wonders than any faith could ever muster. Richard dawkins central argument in the god delusion. In his book the god delusion 2006, british evolutionary biologist, richard dawkins asserts that if the entire evidence in the world favored creationism, he would immediately recognize and shift his stance on the issue. A christian response to the god delusion reprint by andrew wilson isbn.
It may be redundant to mention on this site, but the god delusion by richard dawkins is of course a good start, as well as many books explaining the motivation behind being an atheist by authors like christopher hitchens god is not great, sam harris and daniel dennett. He calls this argument the ultimate boeing 747 gambit. Atheist with a mission critique of dawkins god delusion. Dawkinss main arguments against any form of theism are lacking in weight and certainly not as conclusive as he claims. His the god delusion has been a best seller and exerted tremendous influence. The god delusion why there almost certainly is no god. I think his previous book the blind watchmaker is more highly regarded than the god delusion, even among atheists.
975 86 173 1081 698 279 644 1644 1330 1256 653 662 1280 468 1109 514 447 606 628 1347 1071 305 1222 1251 142 1101 144 330 800